Medicare Plan Comparison

Light green shows which plan appears better for that item.
Viva Medicare Plus (HMO) Humana Gold Plus (HMO)
Monthly plan premium $0 $0
Part B premium reduction / giveback $20 or $2 per month Part B premium buy-down (county-based) (Not listed)
Maximum out-of-pocket per year (medical) $9,250 (does not include Part D drugs) $6,100
Primary care doctor visit $0 copay $0 copay
Specialist visit $25 copay ($0 in a Skilled Nursing Facility) $20 copay
Inpatient hospital stay (per day / per stay) Days 1–6: $375/day; $0 for additional days $295/day for days 1–8;
$0/day for days 9–90
Outpatient surgery – hospital $365 at outpatient hospital $230 copay
Outpatient surgery – surgical center $0 at ambulatory surgical center $155 copay
Emergency room visit $115 copay
(waived if admitted within 24 hours for same condition)
$130 copay
(waived if admitted to same hospital within 24 hours)
Urgent care visit $0 with PCP;
$25 specialist;
about $40 at urgent care clinic
$50 copay
Ambulance (ground or air) $290 per one-way trip Emergency ambulance covered (copay not specified here)
Lab services $0 $0–$50 copay (depending on service and setting)
X-rays $15 per x-ray $0–$125 copay (depending on type and setting)
MRI / CT / other advanced imaging $200 per service ($15 per ultrasound) Diagnostic radiology – imaging: $200–$335 copay;
Nuclear medicine: $200–$325 copay
Other diagnostic tests Included under lab/imaging copays above Clinic diagnostic tests: $10 copay;
Outpatient diagnostic tests: $0–$50 copay;
Sleep study (facility): $20–$45 copay;
Sleep study (home-based): $0 copay;
Wound care: $20 copay
Outpatient surgery (summary) $0 at ambulatory surgical center;
$365 at outpatient hospital;
$365 per observation stay;
$0 for colonoscopy
$230 copay (hospital);
$155 copay (surgical center)
Skilled nursing facility (per day) Days 1–20: $0/day;
Days 21–63: $218/day;
Days 64–100: $0/day
(Not listed here)
Physical / occupational / speech therapy $25 per visit (Not listed here)
Cardiac / pulmonary rehab $15 per visit (Not listed here)
Home health care $0 (Not listed here)
Durable medical equipment (DME) 20% coinsurance ($0 for ostomy supplies) (Not listed here)
Diabetes supplies / insulin $0 per standard-size box for diabetes supplies;
20% for therapeutic shoes/inserts
(Not listed here)
Outpatient mental health / substance use visits $25 per visit; $55 for intensive outpatient / partial hospitalization $35 copay (group or individual therapy)
Inpatient psychiatric hospital Days 1–5: $375/day; $0 for additional days $272/day for days 1–8;
$0/day for days 9–90
(up to 190 lifetime inpatient days in a psychiatric hospital)
Medicare-covered eye exam (medical) $25 copay ($0 for diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma screening) $20 copay; $0 for diabetic eye exam
Routine eye exam $0 (annual routine vision exam) $0 copay (1 per year)
Eyeglasses / contacts allowance Up to $100 per year for prescription eyewear and/or contact lens fitting Up to $150 per year (standard) OR
up to $250 per year at PLUS Provider
(lenses/frames and fitting)
Medicare-covered dental services Copay depends on place of service $20 copay
Routine dental (cleanings, exams, fillings, etc.) Covered under annual dental allowance
(preventive, diagnostic, comprehensive)
$0 copay for:
bitewing x-rays, exams, cleanings, fillings,
simple/surgical extractions, anesthesia with covered service
Annual dental maximum / allowance $700 or $1,000 per year
(amount depends on county)
$3,000 maximum benefit coverage amount per year
Routine hearing exam $0 with PCP; $25 with specialist $0 copay (1 per year)
Hearing aids Through NationsHearing:
OTC hearing aids (pair): member cost range $750–$2,850;
Prescription hearing aids (one per ear): member cost range $500–$1,975
Advanced level: $0 copay, 1 per ear every 3 years;
Premium level: $299 copay, 1 per ear every 3 years
Over-the-counter (OTC) allowance $30 allowance per calendar quarter (Not specified here)
Fitness / gym benefit Silver&Fit program (no cost; fitness centers and digital options) SilverSneakers program (no cost; participating locations and virtual)
24-hour nurse line / telehealth access Telehealth for PCP, some specialists, urgent care,
and mental health; standard visit copays apply.
Includes 24-hour nurse line.
Preventive benefits at $0; emergency and urgent care covered.
(Telehealth details not specified in this text.)
Part D drug deductible $350 deductible for Tier 3–5 drugs.
No deductible for Tier 1–2 drugs.
$0 deductible for Tiers 1–3.
$590 deductible for Tiers 4–5.
Tier 1 (preferred generic) copay $0 for up to 100-day retail supply;
$0 for up to 100-day preferred mail order
$0 copay (retail and mail-order options)
Tier 2 (generic) copay $12 for 30-day retail;
$30 for 100-day retail;
$24 for 100-day preferred mail order
$5 copay (retail);
$5 or $20 mail-order, depending on days' supply
Tier 3 (preferred brand) copay $47 for 30-day retail;
$117.50 for 100-day retail;
$94 for 100-day preferred mail order
$47 copay (retail and mail-order options)
Tier 4 (non-preferred drugs) cost share 42% coinsurance (up to 100-day supply) Initial coverage: 48% coinsurance;
Deductible applies first to Tier 4
Tier 5 (specialty) cost share 29% coinsurance (30-day supply) Initial coverage: 26% coinsurance;
Deductible applies first to Tier 5
Initial coverage limit to reach catastrophic phase After $2,100 out-of-pocket on Part D drugs:
you pay $0 for covered drugs (catastrophic phase)
After $2,100 out-of-pocket on Part D drugs:
you pay $0 for covered drugs for rest of year